Leadership quiz

Introvert or Extrovert at Work? A Quiz for Managers

Half your team thinks out loud. Half thinks first. Find out which way you lean, how it comes across, and how to lead the other half.

12 work momentsAbout 3 minutesNo sign-up

Someone brings you a problem. What comes out of your mouth?

Every manager sits somewhere on this line. Most never check where.

Neither end wins on its own. In a study of 57 stores, the quiet managers made more profit with a team full of ideas, and the loud ones with a team that waited to be told.

12 work moments, four answers each. You get your spot on the line, how it lands with your team, and three moves for leading the other half. Your answers stay in your browser.

Is it better to lead as an introvert or an extrovert?

Neither. It depends on the team in front of you. Extroverts get picked as leaders more often, but once they’re in the job, how well each style works turns on how the team behaves.

In a study of 57 pizza stores, introverted managers made more profit when their staff were full of ideas, because they listened and used them. Extroverted managers did better when staff waited to be told.

Grant, Gino and Hofmann, Academy of Management Journal, 2011

Across 73 studies, extraversion was the personality trait most linked to leadership, more to being picked as the leader than to doing the job well.

Judge, Bono, Ilies and Gerhardt, Journal of Applied Psychology, 2002

In a call centre, the people in the middle brought in more sales than strong introverts or strong extroverts. The gap was small, so read it as a hint, not a rule: range may help.

Grant, Psychological Science, 2013

Most people act more outgoing in some moments and more reserved in others, every day. Your lean is an average, not a box.

Fleeson, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2001

Questions managers ask

Can introverts be good managers?

Yes. Introverted managers tend to listen more and take ideas from below, which is why, in one study of pizza stores, they made more profit than extroverts when their staff were proactive. Where they slip is a quiet team: if nobody speaks first, the room stays quiet.

How do you manage introverts and extroverts in the same team?

Give the question before the meeting, start with two minutes of quiet writing, go round the room and speak last yourself. Then leave a day for second thoughts by message. The thinkers get time, the talkers still get the room.

Why am I an introvert at home and an extrovert at work?

Because most people move along the scale depending on the moment. Research that tracked people through ordinary days found nearly everyone acts outgoing at some points and reserved at others. The role asks for one, and home lets you recover with the other.

Are younger people at work more introverted?

Maybe a little. A 2026 analysis of about 774,000 personality tests over 30 years found people born between 1995 and 2012 score lower on enjoying crowds and seeking excitement than earlier generations. It’s a preprint, not yet peer reviewed, and other studies find no change. What’s clearer is how many younger people like to work: in a 2025 survey of Gen Z workers, 42% preferred email and 7% phone calls.

Is this a personality test?

No. It’s a self-reflection quiz about how you work, not a clinical or validated personality measure. Use it to see your habits as a manager, not to label yourself or anyone in your team.

Read next

Sources: Grant, Gino and Hofmann (2011), Academy of Management Journal 54(3). Judge, Bono, Ilies and Gerhardt (2002), Journal of Applied Psychology 87(4). Grant (2013), Psychological Science. Fleeson (2001), Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 80(6). Diehl and Stroebe (1987), Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 53. McCarthy, Twenge and others (2026), arXiv 2608.18119, preprint. ZeroBounce workplace survey (2025).

Find where you sit, then how you lead

Take the quiz above, then the free Best Of Motivation Leadership Style Quiz.

Start the quiz